OK, Richter's recording could wrinkle some noses but please consider that it happened in 1971 and anyway this is the first version I ever listened to so I'm pretty partial about it.
Gardiner's is for Giovanni & Gustavo (if my memory's good).
Egarr's is really good and I posted it before.
Pinnock's is a Classic (Capital "C")
Lamon's is a mouthful of fresh air.
Harnoncourt's is what you expect...
Goodman's is my favourite, listen to it and let me know... let's start.
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b8229/b82291871859a15ba7d212c1c2b471fb5e91cbbe" alt=""
dir. Sir John Eliot Gardiner
1981
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(89Mb)
-=o=-
dir. Nikolaus Harnoncourt
1981
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(98Mb)
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/37861/378612ac1b0ecc5c6a6c5b95c3a2d4af5b1fbde2" alt=""
dir. Roy Goodman
1992
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(112Mb)
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eb668/eb668ec6c506446a751d3b875d8912c9b0e19f2b" alt=""
dir. Trevor Pinnock
1992
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(123Mb)
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c686/5c686a5cf7804a1b0915430435e42daa06f9ca83" alt=""
dir. Jeanne Lamon
(~1991)
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(87Mb)
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5b5e3/5b5e38f899831c3bd09004e3f282cb05e0c90346" alt=""
dir. Richard Egarr
2007
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(100Mb)
Booklet (16Mb)
DepositFiles - FileFactory
-=o=-
dir. Carl Richter
1971
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(98Mb)
-=o=-
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fee8e/fee8e168b9518078950fcccc03e811d57545ef7e" alt=""
1992
DepositFiles - FileFactory
(98Mb)
-=o=-
You have all the versions except the best one! Minkowski's.
RispondiEliminaYou have all the versions except the best version - Minkowski's!
RispondiEliminaAll are great, but I prefer Pinnock. By the way, can you post the Schutz Christmas Oratorio someday?
RispondiEliminaYesterday I found two comments mentioning Minkowski's version of the Concerti Grossi and now those comments are gone. I want to apologise for this, still I don't know what happened. Anyway I added Minkowski to the post.
RispondiEliminaQuesto commento è stato eliminato dall'autore.
RispondiEliminaAmong Minkowsi, Pinnock and Goodman I prefer, as for style, Goodman because he is, I think, more stylistically baroque: violins has a less high tessitura (less romantic).
RispondiEliminaAs for musicality, besides of Minkowsi takes, I think, license in the tempo very personal, also I prefer Goodman because I flee of all the interpretations that suggest an apex of romanticism to me (on Baroque, indeed!).
Sorry, I don't know express better, my english is very poor.
Thanks a lot and cheers